West Virginia University All-Americans
Total 29
| Wrestler | Season | Weight | Place |
| Brandon Rader | 2007 | 141 | 6th |
| Brandon Rader | 2006 | 141 | 6th |
| Greg Jones OW | 2005 | 184 | 1st |
| Matt Lebe | 2005 | 157 | 7th |
| Greg Jones | 2004 | 184 | 1st |
| Brandon Lauer | 2003 | 133 | 8th |
| Shane Cunanan | 2003 | 141 | 6th |
| Greg Jones | 2002 | 174 | 1st |
| Vertus Jones | 2000 | 184 | 2nd |
| Whitey Chlebove | 1999 | 141 | 6th |
| Sam Kline | 1999 | 174 | 3rd |
| Vertus Jones | 1999 | 184 | 3rd |
| Whitey Chlebove | 1998 | 134 | 7th |
| Mike Mason | 1998 | 150 | 3rd |
| Vertus Jones | 1998 | 177 | 2nd |
| John Koss | 1997 | 177 | 6th |
| Mike Mason | 1997 | 150 | 7th |
| Dean Morrison | 1994 | 177 | 1st |
| Doug Taylor | 1993 | 158 | 5th |
| Mark Banks | 1991 | 167 | 5th |
| Dominick Black | 1991 | 190 | 4th |
| Scott Collins | 1991 | 142 | 1st |
| Mark Banks | 1990 | 167 | 5th |
| Mike Carr | 1988 | 158 | 7th |
| Jim Akerly | 1987 | 150 | 8th |
| Mark Cagle | 1979 | 134 | 8th |
| Lewis Guidi | 1955 | 123 | 2nd |
| Robert Perry | 1955 | 115 | 4th |
| Jimmie Cox | 1929 | 135 | 3rd |